Chicago students react negatively to Arizona law
By Nistha Tamrakar
Sporting events, colleges, students, and illegal immigrants have all been affected by the recent Arizona immigration law that was passed on April 23.
In Arizona, the governor signed the nation’s toughest bill on illegal immigration into law. The law, also known as SB 1070, aims to identify, prosecute, and deport illegal immigrants. This law is scheduled to go into effect on July 28.
The law gives police the power to detain anyone who they have ‘reasonable suspicion’ to believe is undocumented. Many have begun to challenge and protest against this law because it is essentially legalizing racial profiling and discrimination against Hispanics regardless of their citizenship status.
At Lane, social networking sites have increased awareness of this law. Facebook has created a group titled, “1 Million People Saying Shame on Arizona.” It advocates Facebook users to join and take action by sending messages to Arizona’s leaders. It has sayings posted such as, “As long as racial profiling is legal in Arizona, I will do what I can to not visit the state and to avoid spending dollars there.”
Most Lane students have expressed strong opinions about this new law.
“Coming from immigrant parents, [I think] this law is completely bogus and racist,” said Juleny Cruz, Div. 153. “How are you going to judge someone [about] whether they have papers or not by the way they look, or their accent?”
“I think it’s absolutely ridiculous because it is racial profiling and it is sad because we have come such a long way to fight it,” said Meilen Teklemichael, Div. 168.
Ms. Sebestyen a Lane law teacher, held an open discussion about the Arizona law during her class. The students were immensely engaged in the topic and it developed into a heated debate.
“I believe that we should have class discussions about issues like this. Though it might not affect people in Illinois, it is still occurring in our country,” said Arooba Chaudhry, Div. 052.
This law mainly affects Hispanics in Arizona because they are targeting the illegal immigrants that come from the bordering countries, such as Mexico. One Lane Mexican-American student expresses her personal experiences with working with immigrants in Chicago.
“I have volunteered at Latinos Progresando for the past three years, [which] [is] an immigration and legal services organization,” said Gabriela Reno, Div. 053. “I have worked closely with the Dream Act and know what a law like the SB 1070 and other deportations can do to families and bright young students. This country was founded by immigrants and there is no way it would have become such a great place without the handwork of immigrants who have contributed so much to the U.S.”
Recently, Highland Park High School’s Girls’ Basketball team cancelled an upcoming trip to Arizona for a tournament.
“We would want to ensure that all of our students had the opportunity to be included and be safe and be able to enjoy the experience [at the tournament],” said District 113 Assistant Superintendent Suzan Hebson. “We wouldn’t necessarily be able to guarantee that.”
Although it has only been a month and a half since the law was passed, Arizona has been affected in many ways. Many out-of-state students have told the University of Arizona that they are not attending their school because of the law. Groups have been calling and have cancelled meetings and conventional plans in the state. Elementary schools and high schools in Arizona are also concerned that student participation in sports are going to decline. Even the Arizona Diamondbacks are facing the side effects of this law. They expect fewer fans at away games because protest plans may be unfolding in each location.
Though it seems like most people are against this law, there are some that support its mission.
“I am for the new revised Arizona Law. I am against illegal immigration because of the crime that comes with it. I have heard that crime in Arizona has dramatically increased at the same time illegal immigration increased. The crime and drug war in Mexico is spilling over the border into our country and the citizens of Arizona are suffering because of it,” said Krystian Chowaniec, Div. 090. “Hey, don’t get me wrong. I have Latino and white friends that are illegal, and I believe they are good people. I want students to gain residency because they will be assets to our country, [but] just keep the real criminals out.”
“I am against illegal immigration, especially because we are in a recession,” said Darina Veleva, Div. 025. “Legal residents do not have jobs because the illegal residents are working for way less money.”
According to some students, there are alternative solutions to the illegal immigration issue.
“I think the [Arizona] [law] is inappropriate, very extreme, and an unnecessary approach. I think it’s wrong that we need to make people feel uncomfortable in order to achieve something,” said Anastasia Protopappas, Div. 045. “There has to be a different way to regulate immigration and citizenship.”
“They shouldn’t just target certain people like Hispanics. It should be everybody,” said Natalie Gaddini, Div 027.
Besides Arizona, other states, such as Colorado, have considered passing similar immigration laws.
“Arizona is now deporting people at a rate of 1,000 per day — with nearly half of the arrests in the state of Arizona — and now the state legislature is on the verge of escalating that pace dramatically,” said U.S. Representative Luis Guiterrez.
In order to protests against the Arizona law, a group called One Arizona filed paperwork with the Secretary of State’s Office on April 28 to begin a petition drive to overturn S1070. Boycotts in Arizona have also continued to rise everyday in order to stop this law.
